Blog

How to Get Members to Upgrade Their Membership

By
Frano Didovich
November 19, 2026
Share this post
diagonal triangle shape for background image

To get members to upgrade, give them a higher tier with one benefit they clearly want, then ask at the moments they feel the value most: renewal, right after an event, and on their membership anniversary. Make the switch a single click, and track your upgrade rate every month. Moving even 1 in 10 members up a tier can lift your dues revenue without recruiting anyone new.

This guide walks you through how to build an upgrade path, when to ask, how real Join It organizations set up their tiers, ready-to-use email templates, and the numbers to watch.

What is a membership upgrade?

A membership upgrade is when an existing member moves to a higher-priced membership type, such as from Standard to Gold, from Individual to Family, or from a monthly plan to a premium annual plan. The member stays with you, and you earn more from that relationship each year.

Upgrades are one of three ways a membership program grows its revenue:

  • Recruitment: adding new members.
  • Retention: keeping the members you have.
  • Expansion: increasing what each member contributes, through upgrades, add-ons and paid extras.

Most organizations put their energy into the first two. Expansion is often the quickest win, because these people already know and trust you.

How much revenue can membership upgrades add?

Upgrades raise your revenue per member, so every renewal is worth more. Here is a simple example for a club with 400 members, two tiers and annual dues.

  • Standard membership: $60 a year
  • Premium membership: $120 a year, with members-only event pricing and a guest pass
  • Today, 320 members are on Standard and 80 are on Premium

Now say the club moves 10% of its Standard members (32 people) up to Premium over the year.

MeasureBefore upgradesAfter upgradesChange
Standard members ($60) 320 288 -32
Premium members ($120) 80 112 +32
Total members 400 400 No change
Annual dues revenue $28,800 $30,720 +$1,920 (+6.7%)
Average revenue per member $72.00 $76.80 +$4.80

That extra $1,920 matches what 32 brand-new Standard members would bring in. The difference is that the club earned it from people who already know it, with no extra recruitment spend, and the gain repeats every year those members renew.

There is room to grow here for many organizations. In the 2024 Membership Marketing Benchmarking Report from Marketing General Incorporated, the number of membership upgrades was one of only three engagement areas where the share of associations reporting a decline increased, "from 7% to 10%." A clear upgrade plan helps you move the other way.

When are members most likely to upgrade?

Members upgrade when the value of the next tier feels real to them. Plan your asks around these four moments.

At renewal

Renewal is the natural point to review a membership, and members are already at checkout. In Join It, members who click their renewal link can switch to a different membership type during renewal, so an upgrade takes the same few clicks as a standard renewal. Mention the higher tier in your renewal reminders a few weeks ahead so the choice is already on their mind.

Right after a great experience

The days after a sold-out event, a members-only workshop or a busy season are when members feel most connected. If your higher tier includes event discounts or early access, a short note afterward ("Premium members saved $15 on this event") connects the benefit to something they just enjoyed.

On their membership anniversary

A member who has been with you for a full year has proved they value the program. An anniversary email that thanks them and shows what the next tier adds turns loyalty into a natural next step.

When their needs change

A member who starts bringing a partner, a business that hires more staff, or a student who graduates may simply need a different membership. Watch for these signals in your member notes and check-in history, and suggest the type that fits.

How do you build an upgrade path members want?

An upgrade path is the clear, visible step from one tier to the next. Members should be able to see in a sentence what they gain and what it costs. These five levers make that step easy to take.

  1. Lead with one standout benefit. Pick the single perk your most engaged members value most, such as event discounts, guest passes or early booking, and make it the headline of the higher tier. If you are still shaping your levels, our guide on how to structure membership tiers covers the options.
  2. Make the value easy to measure. Benefits with a dollar value are the easiest to say yes to. If Premium costs $60 more and includes six events at $15 off, a regular attendee can see the upgrade pays for itself.
  3. Show the higher tier everywhere members look. Feature it on your join page, in renewal reminders and in member emails, so members see it in the places they already look.
  4. Keep the price gap sensible. A step that feels in proportion to the extra value is easier to accept. Our membership pricing strategy guide walks through how to set it.
  5. Remove friction from switching. Every extra form or email back and forth costs you upgrades. A one-click switch at renewal and a quick admin change mid-term keep the yes simple.

You can also offer a time-limited upgrade discount to get things moving. In Join It, you can create discount codes for your memberships, choose whether a discount applies only to the first payment or continues on automatic renewals, and cap how many times a code can be used.

How do Join It organizations set up tiers that members upgrade into?

The organizations below use Join It to run more than one membership type, each with its own price and benefits. Their setups show what a clear upgrade path looks like in practice.

Frome Festival: Standard and Gold Friends with their own messages

Frome Festival, an arts and cultural charity in Somerset, UK, runs its Friends program on Join It. It offers Standard and Gold memberships, along with free recognition memberships and gift memberships. Each membership type has its own pricing and messages, so each group receives communication that fits. Friends get benefits such as advance booking and discounts from independent local businesses, which they show on a digital membership card.

What to borrow: separate messages per tier let you speak to Standard members about what Gold adds, without sending that note to people who already have it.

Meepleville: benefits members can see and use

Meepleville, a board game cafe with 250 monthly paying members at the time of its case study, gives members visits without the day fee plus added benefits such as guest passes. Staff record redeemed guest passes against the member record, and check-in history shows when someone last visited. The team also creates custom membership types and hides them when needed, so it can offer a family or one-off arrangement without redesigning the whole program.

What to borrow: tracked benefits and visit history show you which members get the most from their membership, which is exactly who to invite to the next tier.

Perth Angels: several types with monthly and annual billing

Perth Angels, a not-for-profit angel investment network in Western Australia, manages professional, education and family memberships with a mix of monthly and annual billing. Monthly membership reports help its committee see growth trends across different membership types.

What to borrow: reviewing your mix of membership types each month shows whether members are moving up, staying put or stepping down.

Humble Grape: a wine club that runs in the background

Humble Grape, a London wine bar and restaurant group, runs its Wine Club on Join It with automatic billing, digital membership cards and a Klaviyo sync for member communication. As Enya Buchena from Humble Grape put it, "It just works in the background, and we don't have to worry about it."

What to borrow: when billing and cards run on their own, your team has time for the personal conversations that lead to upgrades.

How do you run an upgrade campaign in Join It, step by step?

You can set up a simple, repeatable upgrade campaign in an afternoon. Here is how it works in Join It.

  1. Set up your membership types. Create each tier with its own price, billing schedule and renewal settings. Join It plans include unlimited membership types, and you can edit membership types as your program grows. Keep the tiers you want members to switch into visible on your profile, because members can only choose visible types at renewal.
  2. Attach benefits to each tier. If events are part of your higher tier, the Eventbrite integration lets you assign discounts and early access codes by membership type, so Premium members automatically get their perk.
  3. Add the upgrade to your renewal reminders. Automated renewal reminders can target specific membership types and include merge tags. Add a line to your Standard reminder about what Premium includes. When members click the renewal link, they can switch membership types during renewal on the same pre-filled checkout page.
  4. Send targeted upgrade emails. Filter your members by membership type, status and join date to reach, for example, Standard members who joined over a year ago. Send them an anniversary or post-event upgrade invitation.
  5. Offer a limited upgrade discount (optional). Create a discount code, cap the number of uses, and turn off the discount input on your checkout once the promotion ends.
  6. Handle mid-term upgrades personally. If a member wants to upgrade before their renewal date, an admin can change their membership type at any time from the member record.
  7. Let members show off their new tier. On plans that include digital membership cards, a member's card updates automatically when they upgrade, so their new benefits are ready to use straight away.

Good to know: members switch types themselves at renewal, and an admin handles earlier upgrades and changes to group memberships.

What should an upgrade email say?

A good upgrade email is short, personal and focused on one benefit. Copy these three templates and swap in your own details.

Template 1: Renewal reminder with an upgrade option

Subject: Your (organization name) membership renews on (renewal date)

Hi (first name),

Thank you for being part of (organization name) this year. Your (current tier) membership renews on (renewal date), and you can renew in one click with the link below.

When you renew, you can also switch to (higher tier). For (price difference) more a year, you get (standout benefit), plus (second benefit).

(Renewal link)

Thank you for your support, (Your name)

Template 2: After an event

Subject: Thanks for joining us at (event name)

Hi (first name),

It was great to see you at (event name). (One line about the event.)

Quick tip for next time: (higher tier) members get (event benefit), so a member who comes to (number) events a year saves (amount). If you would like to switch, reply to this email and we will update your membership for you.

See you at the next one, (Your name)

Template 3: Membership anniversary

Subject: Happy one year with (organization name), (first name)

Hi (first name),

It has been a year since you joined (organization name), and we are so glad you are here. This year, members like you (one specific result, such as "filled 12 workshops").

If you would like to get even more from your membership, (higher tier) adds (standout benefit) and (second benefit) for (price difference) more a year. Reply to this email or switch at your next renewal.

Thank you for being with us, (Your name)

Which metrics show your upgrades are working?

Track five numbers each month. Together they show whether upgrades are growing revenue and whether upgraded members stay.

MetricHow to calculate itWhat it tells you
Upgrade rate Members who moved to a higher tier this period, divided by members on lower tiers at the start How well your upgrade path and asks are working
Average revenue per member Total dues revenue divided by total active members Whether each member is worth more over time
Tier mix Share of active members on each membership type Whether members are moving up, staying put or stepping down
Downgrade rate Members who moved to a lower tier, divided by members on higher tiers at the start Whether the higher tier delivers on its promise
Renewal rate by tier Members who renewed on each tier, divided by members due to renew on that tier Whether upgraded members stay as well as everyone else

For context, the same benchmarking report found a median membership renewal rate of 85% among associations surveyed, and a median of 75% for first-year members. If your higher tier renews at a similar or better rate than your entry tier, your upgrades are adding lasting revenue.

In Join It, your member database and reports show active members by membership type, so you can pull these numbers without rebuilding a spreadsheet each month.

Is Join It a good fit for growing upgrade revenue?

Join It suits associations, nonprofits, clubs and communities that want several membership tiers, automated renewals and a simple way for members to move up, without a dedicated IT team. Pricing starts under $29 a month, and every plan includes unlimited membership types, automated emails, recurring payments and renewal reminders.

Join It is a strong fit if you want to:

  • Run two or more membership tiers with their own prices, billing schedules and messages
  • Let members switch to a higher tier when they renew
  • Send renewal reminders and targeted emails by membership type
  • Give members benefits they can use straight away, such as event discounts and digital membership cards
  • See your members, payments and renewals in one membership database

Another solution may fit better if you need fully self-service mid-term upgrades with automatic prorated billing, or if your revenue plan depends on detailed major-gift and donor tracking. In that case, a dedicated donor management platform could sit alongside or in place of your membership software.

If you run a nonprofit, see how Join It supports membership management for nonprofits, including dues, donations and members in one account.

Frequently asked questions about membership upgrades

What is a good membership upgrade rate?

The best benchmark is your own. Start by measuring your own rate for three months, then aim to improve it each renewal cycle. Comparing your rate before and after a campaign is the most useful test.

How many membership tiers do I need for upgrades to work?

Two or three main tiers are enough for most organizations. One entry tier and one clearly better tier gives members a simple choice. Read more in how many membership tiers your group should offer.

Should I offer a discount to encourage upgrades?

A short, limited discount can help members try a higher tier. Set a clear end date in your messaging, cap the number of uses, and decide whether the discount continues on renewal or applies to the first payment only.

Can members upgrade in the middle of their membership?

Yes. In Join It, an admin can change a member's membership type at any time. Members can also choose a different type themselves when they renew.

Is moving members from monthly to annual billing an upgrade?

It is a related win. Annual billing gives you revenue up front and fewer renewal points each year. Our guide to monthly vs. annual membership dues explains when each works best.

How do I avoid members feeling pressured to upgrade?

Focus each message on one benefit that fits the member, send it at a natural moment like renewal or an anniversary, and make it easy to stay on their current tier. Members respond well to helpful suggestions that match how they already use the membership.

Grow your revenue with the members you already have

Membership upgrades are one of the quickest ways to grow your revenue, because the people you are asking already value what you do. Give your higher tier one standout benefit, ask at renewal, after events and on anniversaries, make switching simple, and check your upgrade rate every month.

Join It gives you unlimited membership types, renewal reminders by tier and a one-click switch at renewal, so your upgrade path runs alongside your everyday membership work. Start a free Join It trial and set up your first upgrade campaign today.

Share this post
Frano Didovich
Frano Didovich
Account Management

Ready to start your free trial?

Our membership software is intuitive to use and even easier to test for yourself.

No credit card required
No setup cost
No hidden fees
Software Advice — Join It rated 4.7 out of 5
GetApp user reviews — Join It rated 4.7 out of 5
Capterra badge — Join It rated 4.7 out of 5