10 Best Nonprofit Membership Management Software (2025)

Nonprofits are changing fast. Online donations are up, recurring giving is booming, and members expect mobile access to everything.

Yet behind the scenes, too many organizations are still buried in spreadsheets, chasing dues, and manually tracking attendance.

It doesn’t have to be this way. Modern membership management software makes running a nonprofit easier, more efficient, and a lot less stressful.

In this guide, we'll break down:

• Why membership management software is a game-changer for nonprofits
• Must-have features that separate winners from time-wasters
• Real pricing (with hidden costs exposed)
• 10 top software options, starting with our #1 pick
• What real users actually say (including some brutal Reddit reviews)
• A simple decision framework to pick your perfect match

Ready to swap spreadsheet chaos for automated simplicity?

Let's dive in.

Why Nonprofit Membership Management Software Matters

The nonprofit membership landscape is exploding. The global membership management software market is projected to grow from $2.29 billion in 2024 to $2.61 billion in 2025.

That's a whopping 13.6% growth rate.

But why the sudden surge?

The Rise of Recurring Revenue

Monthly giving programs aren't nice-to-have anymore — they're mission-critical. With recurring donations growing 11% annually, smart nonprofits are building sustainable membership models instead of relying on one-off donations.

Cloud-First Expectations

Gone are the days of clunky desktop software. 85% of organizations now demand cloud-based, mobile-accessible tools that let staff work effectively from anywhere.

Your volunteers shouldn't need a computer science degree to send a newsletter.

The Automation Imperative

Manual membership management is killing nonprofit productivity. Time spent on repetitive tasks like invoice generation, renewal reminders, and data entry could be better invested in your actual mission.

As one frustrated nonprofit leader on Reddit put it: "I spend more time managing our member spreadsheet than actually helping people."

The solution? Purpose-built membership management software that handles the boring stuff automatically.

Want more insights on building successful membership programs? Check out our nonprofit membership management hub for expert strategies.

‍

Must-Have Features for Nonprofit Membership Software

Not all membership software is created equal. Some platforms feel like they were designed by people who never actually managed a nonprofit.

Spoiler: they probably were.

Here's what actually matters:

Centralized Member Database & CRM

Your member data shouldn't be scattered across five different tools. Look for platforms that consolidate member profiles, donation history, volunteer hours, and communication preferences in one searchable database.

Pro tip: Test how easy it is to find a specific member's information. If it takes more than 10 seconds, keep looking.

‍

Automated Dues, Renewals & Reminders

Manual renewal reminders are productivity killers. Quality software should automatically:

• Send renewal notices 60, 30, and 7 days before expiration
• Process recurring payments seamlessly
• Update member status automatically
• Handle payment failures gracefully with retry logic

‍

Event Registration & Attendance Tracking

Most nonprofits host events, but managing RSVPs through email is a nightmare. Your software should offer:

• Custom registration forms
• Payment processing for paid events
• Automated confirmation emails
• Check-in tools for event day
• Post-event follow-up automation

‍

Email & Communication Tools

88% of nonprofits use content marketing to build awareness, but your communication tools need to go beyond basic newsletters. Look for:

• Segmentation based on member type, interests, or engagement
• Template libraries for common communications
• A/B testing capabilities
• Integration with your existing email marketing platform

‍

Donation & Fundraising Integrations

The line between membership and donor management is blurring. Modern platforms should seamlessly track both membership dues and additional donations, giving you a complete view of supporter engagement.

‍

Reporting & Analytics Dashboards

You can't improve what you don't measure. Essential reports include:

• Member retention rates
• Revenue trends by membership type
• Event attendance analytics
• Email engagement metrics
• Volunteer participation tracking

‍

Nonprofit-Specific Discounts & Support

Look for platforms that understand nonprofit constraints:

• Dedicated nonprofit pricing tiers
• Discounts for annual payments
• Free trials (30+ days preferred)
• Customer support that actually understands nonprofit operations

‍

Quick Comparison: Top Nonprofit Membership Software

‍

The 10 Best Nonprofit Membership Management Software

Join It

Join It is the Swiss Army knife of nonprofit membership management — powerful enough for complex needs, simple enough that your volunteer coordinator won't need a PhD to use it.

Pricing:

• Monthly: Starting at $29/mo (Starter), $99/mo (Total), $199/mo (Extra)
• Annual: Starting at $26.10/mo with 10% nonprofit discount
• Free Trial: 30 days, no credit card required

⭐ Overall Rating: 4.7 / 5

Secondary Ratings:

• Ease of Use: 4.7 / 5
• Customer Support: 4.9 / 5
• Value for Money: 4.7 / 5
• Functionality: 4.4 / 5

Latest Reviews

Review 1:
Pros: Interface is straightforward, making it easy to add, delete, and check member details. Sending emails is also quick and simple.
Cons: Email options are limited.
⭐ 5-star, Software Advice, February 2024

Review 2:
Pros: Intuitive and easy for the entire team to use. Eventbrite integration, reporting tools, and membership profile management stand out. Customer service is responsive and friendly.
Cons: Could use more customization, but the team always finds solutions.
⭐ 5-star, Software Advice, October 2023

Ready to streamline your membership management? Start your 30-day free trial and see why 2,200+ organizations trust Join It.

‍

Wild Apricot

Wild Apricot positions itself as the all-in-one solution for small associations and clubs, combining membership management with event registration, email marketing, and even website building.

Pricing: Contact-based pricing starting at $63/mo for 100 contacts, scaling up to $945/mo for 50,000 contacts. Annual discounts up to 15% available.

⭐ Overall Rating: 4.4 / 5

Secondary Ratings:

• Ease of Use: 4.3 / 5
• Customer Support: 4.4 / 5
• Value for Money: 4.3 / 5
• Functionality: 4.2 / 5

Latest Reviews

Review 1:
Pros: Users appreciate that Wild Apricot is easy to set up and handles bulk emails, dues dates, and renewals effectively.
Cons: Some users find the software expensive and the support unhelpful, especially after Personify took over. No live help available makes resolving issues harder.
⭐ 1-star, Software Advice, May 2025

Review 2:
Pros: Bulk emailing works well, and managing due dates and renewals is straightforward.
Cons: Users in Canada mention the system has become expensive, with difficulties in customizing webpages and added costs for upgrades. Reporting limitations also create frustration.
⭐ 3-star, Software Advice, April 2025

‍

Hivebrite

Hivebrite focuses on community engagement and is popular with universities, alumni associations, and professional networks seeking to build active online communities.

Pricing: Starting around $799/mo for the Connect plan, with Scale and Enterprise tiers requiring custom quotes.

⭐ Overall Rating: 4.5 / 5

Secondary Ratings:

• Ease of Use: 4.4 / 5
• Customer Support: 4.7 / 5
• Value for Money: 4.5 / 5
• Functionality: 4.3 / 5

Latest Reviews

Review 1:
Pros: Hivebrite’s customer success team is highly praised for being proactive and supportive, often going above and beyond to help nonprofits manage communities effectively. The platform is intuitive and automates much of the workload.
Cons: Building a community online can be challenging since the platform isn’t designed as social media. Some users also feel the 100-member minimum can be a hurdle for smaller groups.
⭐ 5-star, Software Advice, July 2025

Review 2:
Pros: Users value Hivebrite’s modular design, which makes it easy to adapt the platform to community needs. Customer service is described as friendly, knowledgeable, and responsive.
Cons: A few mention the back-office features could feel limited at times, though manageable once familiar.
⭐ 5-star, Software Advice, July 2025

‍

Brilliant Directories

Brilliant Directories specializes in creating searchable member directories and monetizing membership listings — perfect for professional associations or business networks.

Pricing: Standard plan at $145/mo or Lifetime option for $1,450 one-time payment.

⭐ Overall Rating: 4.8 / 5

Secondary Ratings:

• Ease of Use: 4.5 / 5
• Customer Support: 4.8 / 5
• Value for Money: 4.8 / 5
• Functionality: 4.7 / 5

Latest Reviews

Review 1:
Pros: Easy to customize and create a directory without relying on WordPress plugins. Saves time and simplifies setup for users who aren’t web experts.
Cons: Adding multiple websites requires a new plan, which can be costly for those managing more than one site.
⭐ 4-star, Software Advice, June 2025

Review 2:
Pros: Great customer service with responsive support. Users like being able to start websites with built-in business directories, helping local businesses claim and manage their pages.
Cons: Some users would appreciate more tutorial videos to explore the full potential of the platform.
⭐ 5-star, Software Advice, May 2025

‍

MemberPlanet

MemberPlanet aims to simplify membership and donor management for nonprofits and schools with communication tools, event registration, and fundraising features.

Pricing: Free basic plan available, paid plans from $50-$175/mo plus platform fees.

⭐ Overall Rating: 4.7 / 5

Secondary Ratings:

• Ease of Use: 4.5 / 5
• Customer Support: 4.8 / 5
• Value for Money: 4.5 / 5
• Functionality: 4.3 / 5

Latest Reviews

Review 1:
Pros: MemberPlanet streamlines membership processes and conference registrations, saving valuable time. Users found the platform easy to navigate and appreciated the strong customer support.
Cons: Website building tools are more limited compared to transferring or customizing content.
⭐ 5-star, Software Advice, August 2025

Review 2:
Pros: Flexible and easy-to-use system that supports event registration, membership management, and content updates. Particularly helpful for organizations transitioning from older systems.
Cons: Documentation and support can sometimes feel inconsistent, especially when using external hosting platforms.
⭐ 5-star, Software Advice, August 2024

‍

Member365

Member365 takes a modular approach, allowing organizations to customize their membership management system by choosing specific features and add-ons.

Pricing: Starting at $299/mo with custom quotes based on chosen modules and member count.

⭐ Overall Rating: 4.3 / 5

Secondary Ratings:

• Ease of Use: 4.2 / 5
• Customer Support: 4.4 / 5
• Value for Money: 4.4 / 5
• Functionality: 4.2 / 5

Latest Reviews

Review 1:
Pros: Member365 is praised for its user-friendly setup and strong support team. Organizations note that the system helps them work more efficiently and the customer service is quick to provide solutions.
Cons: Some users find there are too many settings, making it difficult to navigate. Language support for non-English speakers is also limited.
⭐ 5-star, Software Advice, July 2025

Review 2:
Pros: Responsive help team that not only solves issues but also provides practical suggestions for improvement. The system allows detailed reporting and compliance-friendly email communication.
Cons: A few users felt the interface could be more intuitive, with some tasks taking extra effort compared to expectations.
⭐ 4-star, Software Advice, April 2025

‍

AssoConnect

Developed in France, AssoConnect integrates membership management with accounting, website building, and fundraising — particularly popular with European nonprofits.

Pricing: Three tiers - Free (Liberté), €26/mo (Sérénité), €104/mo (Professionnelle)

⭐ Overall Rating: 4.7 / 5

Secondary Ratings:

• Ease of Use: 4.6 / 5
• Customer Support: 4.6 / 5
• Value for Money: 4.5 / 5
• Functionality: 4.6 / 5

Latest Reviews

Review 1:
Pros: Users find AssoConnect to be an essential tool for managing associations, especially praising its ease of use and the wide range of modules like event management, accounting, and member database. Customer support is responsive and supportive.
Cons: Some users noted price increases over time and challenges contacting support by phone during busy periods.
⭐ 4-star, Software Advice, September 2024

Review 2:
Pros: Described as complete and efficient software, it integrates well with accounting features and helps manage associations effectively.
Cons: Some advanced features come with additional costs, and users mentioned limitations in automated recognition of invoices.
⭐ 4-star, Software Advice, June 2024

‍

iMIS

iMIS is an enterprise-grade Engagement Management System (EMS) designed for large associations and nonprofits with complex requirements.

Pricing: Professional tier starting at $7,200/year ($600/mo) for minimum 3 users, with implementation costs ranging $15,000-$50,000.

⭐ Overall Rating: 4.4 / 5

Secondary Ratings:

• Ease of Use: 4.0 / 5
• Customer Support: 4.1 / 5
• Value for Money: 4.1 / 5
• Functionality: 4.2 / 5

Latest Reviews

Review 1:
Pros: Users highlight the system’s versatility, with options that can be tailored to organizational needs. Templates and third-party integrations are also appreciated.
Cons: Some report that setup and configuration can be complex, requiring additional checks and effort to manage.
⭐ 5-star, Software Advice, July 2025

Review 2:
Pros: iMIS has reduced manual tasks significantly, helping save staff time. Automated processes and reporting make it easier to manage members and focus on strategic initiatives.
Cons: Some users feel licensing costs add up quickly, and a few functions from older versions are no longer available after migration.
⭐ 5-star, Software Advice, January 2025

‍

MemberNova

MemberNova emphasizes member engagement through social networking features and sophisticated onboarding workflows.

Pricing: Starting around $250/mo (though some sources indicate plans beginning at $99/mo).

⭐ Overall Rating: 4.7 / 5

Secondary Ratings:

• Ease of Use: 4.3 / 5
• Value for Money: 5.0 / 5
• Customer Support: 5.0 / 5
• Functionality: 4.3 / 5

Latest Reviews

Review 1:
Pros: Customer service is consistently praised as exceptional, with staff going above and beyond to support organizations. Users also find the platform reliable and effective for membership management.
Cons: Some web and email templates could be updated more often, though MemberNova support has accommodated special requests when needed.
⭐ 5-star, Software Advice, June 2022

Review 2:
Pros: Strong customer support and responsive team. Many users value the ability to manage large-scale data while simplifying workflows.
Cons: A few users experienced limitations with certain customization features that could not be fixed despite requests.
⭐ 4-star, Software Advice, February 2022

‍

ePhilanthrAppeal

ePhilanthrAppeal combines membership management with comprehensive fundraising tools, making it ideal for nonprofits where membership and donation activities overlap significantly.

Pricing: Starting at $95/mo for basic plans.

⭐ Overall Rating: 5.0 / 5

Secondary Ratings:

• Ease of Use: 5 / 5
• Customer Support: 5 / 5
  
  

Latest Reviews

Review 1:
Pros: Users highlight the software’s ease of use, affordability, and strong reporting tools. Customer support is described as friendly, fast, and helpful, with training and customization options available.
Cons: Some mention that there are many features, which can feel overwhelming at first.
⭐ 5-star, Software Advice, May 2011

Review 2:
Pros: Praised for its user-friendly design and valuable online training, which helps nonprofits maximize the system’s potential. Users also appreciate its affordability compared to alternatives.
Cons: While complete, not all features are used by every organization, meaning some tools go underutilized.
⭐ 5-star, Software Advice, August 2008

‍

What Real Users Say (From Reviews & Communities)

Common Praise

Easy Setup Winners: Join It, AssoConnect, and ePhilanthrAppeal consistently earn praise for intuitive onboarding processes that don't require technical expertise.

Support Superstars: MemberNova and Join It receive high marks for responsive, knowledgeable customer support that actually understands nonprofit challenges.

Feature Completeness: iMIS and Wild Apricot get recognition for comprehensive functionality, though this sometimes comes at the cost of complexity.

Common Complaints

UI Disasters: As one Reddit user bluntly stated about MemberPlanet: "the worst UI in the world" with persistent bugs and limited functionality.

Support Deterioration: Wild Apricot faces ongoing criticism for declining customer service quality, with users reporting difficulty reaching knowledgeable support staff after corporate changes.

Hidden Costs Surprise: iMIS and Member365 users frequently mention unexpected setup fees and per-member charges that significantly exceed advertised pricing.

Customization Limitations: Both Brilliant Directories and MemberNova receive criticism for limited customization options that force workarounds for unique organizational needs.

This is why platforms like Join It stand out — they prioritize user experience and transparent pricing. Explore Join It's nonprofit solutions to see the difference.

‍

How to Choose the Right Nonprofit Membership Software

Match Your Nonprofit Size & Needs

Small nonprofits/clubs (Under 500 members): Join It, MemberPlanet, or AssoConnect offer affordable entry points with essential features.

Community-focused organizations: Hivebrite and MemberNova excel at member engagement and networking features.

Large associations (1000+ members): iMIS and Member365 provide enterprise-grade functionality for complex operations.

Directory-based organizations: Brilliant Directories specializes in searchable member listings and monetization.

Fundraising-heavy nonprofits: ePhilanthrAppeal seamlessly blends membership and donor management.

Budget & Hidden Costs Checklist

Before committing, calculate total cost of ownership:

• Setup fees: Can range from $0 to $50,000 for enterprise solutions
• Transaction fees: Typically 1.5-4% per payment processed
• Per-member costs: Some platforms charge monthly fees per active member
• Annual discounts: Most offer 10-15% savings for annual payments
• Nonprofit rates: Many platforms offer special pricing for qualified nonprofits

Always Test With a Free Trial

Simulate real workflows during your trial period:

• Import a sample of your current member data
• Test the renewal process from a member's perspective
• Send a newsletter to a test group
• Generate reports you'll actually use
• Contact customer support with a real question

Pro tip: Include your volunteers in the testing process. If they can't figure out basic functions, the software isn't right for your organization.

‍

Frequently Asked Questions

‍

What is nonprofit membership management software?

Cloud-based tools that centralize member data, automate renewals and payments, and streamline communication and events. Think of it as your digital membership coordinator that never takes a sick day.

‍Why do nonprofits need it?

Manual membership management kills productivity and member experience. Software automates repetitive tasks, improves communication, and provides data insights that help grow your membership base.

What features matter most?

Centralized member database, automated renewals, email marketing tools, event management, payment processing, and analytics. Mobile accessibility is increasingly important as volunteers work from various locations.

How is it different from donor management software?

While donor CRMs focus on gifts and fundraising campaigns, membership software handles recurring dues, member benefits, and subscription-like relationships. Many modern platforms blend both functions.

‍Which is best for small vs large nonprofits?

Small nonprofits benefit from user-friendly, affordable options like Join It or AssoConnect. Large organizations may need enterprise solutions like iMIS or Member365, despite higher complexity and costs.

‍

Final Thoughts: Pick the Best Nonprofit Membership Software

The nonprofit landscape is evolving rapidly. With recurring giving growing 11% annually and organizations demanding mobile-first solutions, the right membership management software isn't just nice to have — it's essential for survival.

The key is finding the sweet spot between functionality and usability. You need software powerful enough to handle your requirements but simple enough that volunteers can use it effectively.

Our recommendation? Start with a platform that prioritizes user experience and transparent pricing. Test multiple options during their free trial periods. Pay attention to customer support quality — you'll need their help more than you think.

Most importantly, choose software that grows with your mission rather than limiting it.

If you're ready to swap spreadsheets for simplicity and transform your membership management, start your free Join It trial today. With 30 days to test all features and no credit card required, you've got nothing to lose except the membership management headaches.

Want to explore pricing options? Check out Join It's nonprofit-friendly pricing plans with special discounts for qualified organizations.

‍

Sources

1. Kindful. Nonprofit Glossary: Membership Management Software
2. Join It. Best Membership Software for Associations
3. The Business Research Company. Association Management Software Global Market Report
4. Reddit. Anyone Used a Membership Management Software?
5. Reddit. Wild Apricot Discussion
6. AAM Community. Museum Forum Discussion
7. Stack Exchange. Membership Management Software

‍