YourMembership vs. Join It
A sharper alternative to YourMembership
YourMembership is a full association management system, starting at $3,990 a year, with an implementation that reviewers say takes around three months. Join It is all-in-one membership software you can set up in days: payments, automated renewals, member emails, event registration and Wallet cards, from $29 a month. Join It is rated 4.7 on Capterra, against YourMembership’s 3.8.
Clean, modern interface
Transparent pricing
Integrates with the tools you already use
Here’s what happens when YourMembership users switch to Join It
Built to support your workflow, not replace it
Join It offers all the essential membership tools, without forcing you into a closed ecosystem.
Member Timeline
Track key actions across each member’s lifecycle (no CRM degree required).
Useful Integrations
Join It integrates directly with the tools associations use most, Mailchimp, Eventbrite, QuickBooks, plus thousands more through Zapier on every plan.
Custom Checkout Options
Add optional donations, create flexible membership types, and set up one‑time or recurring payments.
Quick, Easy Setup
Get started in minutes. Everything’s self-serve, with fast support if you need help.
.svg)
.svg)
.svg)
Feature by feature, here’s how it compares
From ease of configuration to total cost of ownership, see why Join It is the smarter, leaner choice.
Join It
Use with your existing website
Join It
Alternative
Custom membership types
Join It
Alternative
Multiple admin access
Join It
Alternative
Custom fields on member profiles
Join It
Alternative
Digital membership cards
Join It
Alternative
Automated renewal emails
Join It
Alternative
Member activity timeline
Join It
Alternative
Event management
Join It
Alternative
Public and private directories
Join It
Alternative
Mailchimp and Zapier integration
Join It
Alternative
Transparent pricing
Join It
Alternative
No onboarding fees
Join It
Alternative
Fast, human support
Join It
Alternative
What sets Join It apart
Membership-first simplicity
Join It
Lean, focused, and instantly usable.
YourMembership
Comprehensive, but often overwhelming for smaller teams.
Flat-rate, clear pricing
Join It
No tier-bloat or quote games.
YourMembership
High annual cost with hidden complexity.
Digital membership cards included
Join It
QR-ready cards out of the box.
YourMembership
No card feature.
Plug-and-play integrations
Join It
Connects to key tools upfront.
YourMembership
Requires higher plans or addons for integrations.
How YourMembership & Join It are alike
Both include membership portals, events, automation, directories, marketing, and payment capabilities.
Both include membership portals, events, automation, directories, marketing, and payment capabilities.
Both support institutions and associations with multi-level member structures.
Both support institutions and associations with multi-level member structures.
Both offer support and hosted options—Join It just packages the essentials into one clear and affordable plan.
Both offer support and hosted options—Join It just packages the essentials into one clear and affordable plan.
Join It vs YourMembership pricing
Join It
Starting at
$29
/mo
Transparent, unlimited feature access
Includes digital membership cards, integrations, and timeline
30-day free trial—no card needed
Starting from
$3,990
/mo
/yr
All-in-one AMS quote-based pricing
Includes events, websites, CRM, e-commerce, automation, reporting, portals, etc.
Often requires implementation services and customization
What is the best YourMembership alternative for membership management?
Join It is a strong YourMembership alternative for organizations that want modern membership management software that is simpler to set up, easier to manage, transparently priced, and focused on the core membership workflows they use every day.
How does Join It compare to YourMembership?
Join It and YourMembership both help organizations manage memberships, payments, renewals, events, and member data. The main difference is that Join It is designed as a focused membership management platform, while YourMembership is a broader association management system.
Is Join It a better fit if I want membership-first software instead of a full AMS?
Yes. Join It is a strong fit for organizations that want powerful membership management without paying for, implementing, or maintaining a full association management system they may not fully use.
Why do organizations consider switching from Your Membership to Join It?
Organizations often consider Join It as a YourMembership alternative when they want a simpler admin experience, transparent monthly pricing, faster setup, flexible integrations, and modern member features like digital membership cards.
Is Join It easier to set up and manage than YourMembership?
For organizations that want a self-serve membership platform, Join It can be easier to set up and manage. You can sign up, import members, configure memberships, and launch without requiring a formal implementation project.
Can Join It support chapters, branches, or multi-level membership structures?
Yes. Join It can support organizations with chapters, branches, clubs, or other multi-level structures through its Multi-Chapter feature, available as part of Enterprise packages.
How do Join It and YourMembership compare on pricing and implementation cost?
Join It publishes transparent pricing starting at $29/month, while YourMembership uses personalized quote-based pricing. The right comparison depends on your organization’s size, feature needs, implementation requirements, and how much of a full AMS you plan to use.
Can I migrate from YourMembership to Join It?
Yes. Organizations can migrate member data from YourMembership to Join It by exporting their records and importing them into Join It’s member database, with bulk import included for free on every Join It plan.
Real people. Exceptional support.
Clubs, associations and nonprofits in 40+ countries run their membership on Join It — and tell us about it in public.
“We have tripled our membership since using Join It. All our records are in one place, while automated emails, renewals, payments and receipts save us so much time.”
“I now know of only 2 membership management companies — Join It and others. I'm normally reserved on reviews but this one deserves more than my normal polite comments. Exceptional experience.”
“Join It has rescued us from WildApricot. This company understands the modern world. They integrate with the best technologies. And they excel in service, knowing that's the best way to serve their bottom line.”
Try Join It and see the difference
No pressure. No credit card. Just modern membership software that works the way you do.
YourMembership vs Join It: how to choose
The short answer: YourMembership suits associations that need a job board, online learning and an online community in one AMS. It costs from around $3,990 a year as of September 2026, and reviewers say implementation takes about three months. Join It suits associations that want member records, renewals and payments running within days, with simple event registration and targeted member emails built in. When you need more, Join It integrates directly with tools like Eventbrite, Mailchimp and QuickBooks, and connects to thousands more through Zapier, on every plan. Plans start from $29 a month, there’s a 30-day free trial, and Apple Wallet and Google Wallet cards come with the Total plan.
How much does YourMembership cost?
As of September 2026, review sites including Capterra list YourMembership from $3,990 a year, with quote-based pricing beyond that. YourMembership doesn't publish full pricing. Reviewers report that implementation takes around three months, and some integrations, such as the QuickBooks connector, cost extra. There's no free trial listed. Ask YourMembership for a quote that includes implementation and any add-ons you'll need.
Is YourMembership cheaper than Join It?
No. YourMembership starts at around $3,990 a year, with implementation and some integrations extra. Join It starts at $29 a month, month to month, with no setup fees and a platform fee of 1.5% to 3% depending on your plan.
Join It publishes all of its pricing. Plans start at $29 a month on Starter (3% platform fee). Total, at $99 a month (2%), adds digital membership cards, member check-in, a member directory and API access, and Extra, at $199 a month (1.5%), adds custom domains and a dedicated account manager. Plans are month to month, Stripe's processing fees apply, and there are no setup fees. Annual billing saves 10%, and nonprofits get an additional 10% off. See full pricing.
Who owns YourMembership?
YourMembership is part of Momentive Software, which also owns several other association platforms, including MemberClicks. It's a full AMS: a website builder, event management with an event app, a career center and job board, a learning management system and an online community sit alongside member records and dues.
YourMembership suits an association that wants a website, events, a job board, learning and a community under one contract, and has staff to run them.
When is Join It the better choice?
Join It is the better choice for associations that want member records, renewals, payments, simple events and member emails in one easy system, from $29 a month with a 30-day free trial. Join It is usually the better fit if:
- You don't need a job board, learning platform or community. YourMembership bundles them into pricing that starts at around $3,990 a year. Join It covers membership, renewals and payments, with simple event registration and targeted member emails built in, from $29 a month.
- You want to be live in days, not months. Reviewers report that YourMembership implementation takes around three months. Join It is designed to set up and run yourself, with no implementation project.
- You want to keep your existing website. YourMembership is built around its own website builder. Join It works with the site you already have, including sites on WordPress, Squarespace and Wix. If you need a simple online home for your members, the Join It member portal gives you one without building a whole site: share posts, list upcoming events and give members a searchable directory (Total plan and above).
- You use QuickBooks. Reviewers report that YourMembership charges extra for its QuickBooks connector. With Join It, membership payments sync automatically to QuickBooks Online, creating the customer, invoice and payment for you, on every plan at no extra cost.
- You want membership on members' phones, not in an event app. YourMembership runs events through its own event app. On Join It's Total plan and above, members get digital membership cards in Apple Wallet or Google Wallet that show live status, can be scanned to check in at the door, and work alongside events you run with Join It's built-in event registration.
- You want to try it first. YourMembership doesn't list a free trial. Join It has a 30-day free trial, no credit card needed.
When YourMembership may be the better fit
YourMembership may be a better fit than Join It if:
- You need a job board, online learning or an online community in the same system as your member records.
- You want your website built and hosted by your membership platform.
- You run large conferences and want a dedicated event app.
What reviewers say
Ratings as of September 30, 2026:
On Capterra, as of September 30, 2026, Join It scores 4.7 from 83 reviews and YourMembership scores 3.8 from 175; on G2, Join It scores 4.7 from 22 reviews and YourMembership scores 3.3 from 23.
Reviewers of YourMembership value its breadth of features. The most common complaints are a dated interface, slow performance and price increases. Join It reviewers most often mention how easy it is to set up and use.
Can I switch from YourMembership to Join It without members re-entering card details?
Yes, if your members already pay through your own Stripe account: Join It's team can bring their existing Stripe subscriptions across, so they won't need to re-enter their card details. If your YourMembership contract is up for renewal:
- Check your renewal date and notice period in your agreement.
- Start a Join It free trial ahead of time, so you can set up membership types and renewal emails without pressure.
- Export your member records from YourMembership and import them into Join It. Bulk import is free on every plan. Join It's team can do the import for you on any plan, even during your free trial.
- Plan the payment switch. If you use a different payment processor, members will set up card payments with Stripe when they next renew, so time the move before your main renewal period.
Questions to ask before you choose
- Which features will we actually use: a job board, learning, a community?
- What will the first year cost in total, including implementation and add-ons?
- How long until we're live, and who on our team does the work?
- Can we keep our current website and tools?
- How will members prove their membership at events?
Join It is trusted by more than 4,000 membership organizations in 40 countries and has processed over $100 million in membership payments since 2016.
Comparing other options? See all Join It alternatives and comparisons.
Last reviewed: October 1, 2026. YourMembership pricing is taken from Capterra and review sites, and ratings from Capterra and G2. Both may change. Check with YourMembership directly before making a decision.
