MembershipWorks vs. Join It

A smarter alternative to MembershipWorks

MembershipWorks offers a full-featured membership system with hosted and plugin options—including directories, events, donations, job boards, classifieds, and CMS integration across platforms. But its account-tiered pricing, add-on complexity, and feature saturation can overwhelm. Join It gives you the core membership tools you truly need—without tiers, clutter, or unnecessary components.

Clean, modern interface

Transparent pricing

Integrates with the tools you already use

Here’s what happens when MembershipWorks users switch to Join It

Before (with MembershipWorks)
Overbuilt platform with a wide range of bundled features that add complexity
Account-tiered pricing that scales costs as your membership grows
Feature-heavy system that requires ongoing configuration and oversight
Reliance on plugins and CMS integrations that increase maintenance overhead
Harder to keep your setup lean as needs evolve
After (with Join It)
Simple, modern interface focused on core membership needs
Flat, transparent pricing from $29/month with no tiers or per-member fees
Works seamlessly with the tools you already use
Essential membership features without unnecessary add-ons
Fast, self-serve setup with responsive, human support

Built to support your workflow, not replace it

Join It offers all the essential membership tools, without forcing you into a closed ecosystem.

Member Timeline

Member Timeline

Track key actions across each member’s lifecycle (no CRM degree required).

Useful Integrations

Useful Integrations

Connect Join It to Eventbrite, Mailchimp, Zapier, and Stripe to keep everything in sync.

Custom Checkout Options

Custom Checkout Options

Add optional donations, create flexible membership types, and set up one‑time or recurring payments.

Quick, Easy Setup

Quick, Easy Setup

Get started in minutes. Everything’s self-serve, with fast support if you need help.

Feature by feature, here’s how it compares

From ease of configuration to total cost of ownership, see why Join It is the smarter, leaner choice.

Join It

Use with your existing website

Join It

Alternative

Custom membership types

Join It

Alternative

Multiple admin access

Join It

Alternative

Custom fields on member profiles

Join It

Alternative

Digital membership cards

Join It

Alternative

Automated renewal emails

Join It

Alternative

Member activity timeline

Join It

Alternative

Event management

Join It

Alternative

Public and private directories

Join It

Alternative

Mailchimp and Zapier integration

Join It

Alternative

Transparent pricing

Join It

Alternative

No onboarding fees

Join It

Alternative

Fast, human support

Join It

Alternative

What sets Join It apart

Perfectly focused membership UX

Join It

Tailored, intuitive, and uncluttered.

MembershipWorks

Mighty—but may overwhelm smaller teams with breadth.

Product Illustration

One flat rate, always

Join It

No surprises; all features included.

MembershipWorks

Pricing scales with member count, complex to estimate.

Product Illustration

Membership cards built-in

Join It

Digital cards included from the start.

MembershipWorks

Has directories—but not modern mobile card tools.

Product Illustration

Integrations that just work

Join It

Instant connections without templates or plugins.

MembershipWorks

CMS integration setup, with paid add-ons (Mailchimp Premium).

Product Illustration

How MembershipWorks & Join It are alike

Both offer directories, event tools, communications, billing, and CRM features.

Both offer directories, event tools, communications, billing, and CRM features.

Both support admin controls and member self-service.

Both support admin controls and member self-service.

Both serve associations, chambers, and nonprofits effectively.

Both serve associations, chambers, and nonprofits effectively.

Join It vs MembershipWorks pricing

Join It

Starting at

$29

/mo

Single-flat rate—unlimited features included

Digital membership cards, integrations, timeline—all built-in

30-day free trial—no card required

Starting for

Free(up to 50 members)

/mo

/yr

Paid tiers scale from $35/month (300 members) to $259/month (10,000+ members)

All features included across plans

Costs increase as member counts grow, adding complexity for larger organizations

Any questions on this Join It as an alternative to MembershipWorks?

Frequently Asked Questions about MembershipWorks vs Join It

What is the best MembershipWorks alternative for organizations that need membership operations, not just website tools?

Join It is a strong MembershipWorks alternative for organizations that want a dedicated membership platform for records, dues, renewals, events, and member engagement.

Expand Answer

MembershipWorks can be useful for organizations that want membership features connected closely to a website, directory, or web-based membership setup. Join It is a better fit when the main priority is operating the membership program itself: organizing member records, collecting dues, automating renewals, managing events, issuing digital cards, and syncing data with the tools your team already uses. Capterra rates Join It 4.7 overall and 4.9 for customer service, reflecting the 4,000+ organizations that have managed over $100M in membership payments on the platform since 2016. This helps separate membership operations from website maintenance while keeping both connected.

How does Join It compare to MembershipWorks for directories and member records?

MembershipWorks has strong website and directory-style use cases, while Join It is focused on the full member record and the workflows around it.

Expand Answer

A directory is useful, but most membership organizations also need to know who has paid, who is active, who needs to renew, who attended events, and what each member’s history looks like. Join It keeps member data, payment activity, renewals, event registration, digital cards, and member status connected in one platform. If your directory is only one part of a broader membership program, Join It gives your team a stronger operational foundation.

Can I migrate from MembershipWorks to Join It?

Yes. Organizations can move from MembershipWorks to Join It by exporting member data and importing it into Join It’s member database, with bulk import included for free on every Join It plan.

Expand Answer

A MembershipWorks migration usually starts by separating directory information from the operational data your team needs to manage: membership levels, member status, renewal dates, contact details, custom fields, and payment-related records where available. Join It’s bulk import can bring those records into a central member database, where you can rebuild membership types, set up renewals, connect payments, and keep your website or directory experience linked to a more complete membership workflow.

Purple dot background gradient

Top-rated customer support

4.7 Stars on Capterra

Purple dot background gradient
ZFIT found Join It to be very simple to understand due to its clean layout and stellar customer support. Would highly recommend to anyone looking for membership software!
ZFIT
Bernd Z.
The Modern Whig Institute appreciated how easy it was to set up their membership program and then make adjustments as needed. Would highly recommend Join It to others.
Modern Whig Institute
Kevin J Rogers
Easily handles our membership management needs with a minimum of fuss. Excellent value for the money. Tremendous customer support (can't say this enough!)
The Orient Association
Tony A.

Try Join It and see the difference

No pressure. No credit card. Just modern membership software that works the way you do.

30 day free trial
Transparent pricing
Quick setup and live support
Sofware advice star badge
GetApp user reviews star badge
Capterra star badge