Memberful vs. Join It

A smarter alternative to Memberful

Memberful provides creators with a powerful membership suite—ticketing content, gated posts, referral programs, and subscription management—wrapped into a modern, branded experience. But with high transaction fees, platform charges, and plugin complexity, it can weigh you down. Join It gives you exactly what you need for modern membership management—without the hidden costs or developer setup.

Clean, modern interface

Transparent pricing

Integrates with the tools you already use

Here’s what happens when Memberful users switch to Join It

Before (with Memberful)
Creator-focused platform with tools that go beyond core membership needs
Platform fees plus ongoing transaction costs on every payment
Plugin and integration complexity that increases technical overhead
Revenue leakage as fees scale with your success
Less flexibility for organizations that need simple, membership-first workflows
After (with Join It)
Clean, modern interface built for straightforward membership management
Transparent pricing from $29/month with no transaction fees or revenue cuts
Integrates easily with the tools you already use
Core membership features without code, plugins, or complexity
Fast, self-serve setup with responsive, human support

Built to support your workflow, not replace it

Join It offers all the essential membership tools, without forcing you into a closed ecosystem.

Member Timeline

Member Timeline

Track key actions across each member’s lifecycle (no CRM degree required).

Useful Integrations

Useful Integrations

Connect Join It to Eventbrite, Mailchimp, Zapier, and Stripe to keep everything in sync.

Custom Checkout Options

Custom Checkout Options

Add optional donations, create flexible membership types, and set up one‑time or recurring payments.

Quick, Easy Setup

Quick, Easy Setup

Get started in minutes. Everything’s self-serve, with fast support if you need help.

Feature by feature, here’s how it compares

From ease of configuration to total cost of ownership, see why Join It is the smarter, leaner choice.

Join It

Use with your existing website

Join It

Alternative

Custom membership types

Join It

Alternative

Multiple admin access

Join It

Alternative

Custom fields on member profiles

Join It

Alternative

Digital membership cards

Join It

Alternative

Automated renewal emails

Join It

Alternative

Member activity timeline

Join It

Alternative

Event management

Join It

Alternative

Public and private directories

Join It

Alternative

Mailchimp and Zapier integration

Join It

Alternative

Transparent pricing

Join It

Alternative

No onboarding fees

Join It

Alternative

Fast, human support

Join It

Alternative

What sets Join It apart

Membership-first simplicity

Join It

Clean, intuitive, no hidden layers.

Memberful

Rich features, but at a high ongoing cost.

Product Illustration

Keep 100% of your revenue

Join It

No transaction fees—what you earn is yours.

Memberful

You pay 4.9% plus Stripe fees—eating into profits

Product Illustration

Digital cards included by default

Join It

QR-enabled cards—free and built-in.

Memberful

You pay 4.9% plus Stripe fees—eating into profits

Product Illustration

Integrations ready to go

Join It

Plug-and-play with essential tools.

Memberful

Setup required via settings or API.

Product Illustration

How Memberful & Join It are alike

Both unlock gated content, recurring billing, coupon codes, and trials.

Both unlock gated content, recurring billing, coupon codes, and trials.

Both offer dashboards, payment processing, email management, and analytics.

Both offer dashboards, payment processing, email management, and analytics.

Both serve creators—but only Join It offers that experience without long-term cost leakage.

Both serve creators—but only Join It offers that experience without long-term cost leakage.

Join It vs Memberful pricing

Join It

Starting at

$29

/mo

Transparent, all-inclusive pricing

No transaction or platform fees

Includes digital cards, integrations, and core features

30-day free trial—no card required

Starting at

$49

/mo

/yr

Transaction fee of 4.9% applies on all sales

Includes unlimited members, coupon codes, API access, referrals, analytics, and custom branding

Requires Stripe, with additional processing fees that can add up

Any questions on this Join It as an alternative to Memberful?

Frequently Asked Questions about Memberful vs Join It

What is the best Memberful alternative for organizations, clubs, and associations?

Join It is a strong Memberful alternative for organizations that need to manage members, dues, renewals, events, and member records rather than sell creator subscriptions or paid content.

Expand Answer

Memberful can be a good fit for creators, publishers, and independent businesses selling paid memberships, private podcasts, newsletters, or content access. Join It is a better fit when membership represents a real organization with people, participation, dues, events, benefits, and renewal workflows. Join It gives teams a member database, membership types, recurring payments, renewal reminders, event registration, digital membership cards, and member portals built for operational membership management.

How does Join It compare to Memberful for non-creator membership programs?

Memberful is built around creator monetization and content access, while Join It is built around managing an organization’s members and member lifecycle.

Expand Answer

A creator membership usually needs paid access, subscriptions, private content, and audience monetization. An organization membership needs records, dues, renewals, events, attendance, member benefits, and admin workflows. Join It is designed for the second model. It helps teams understand who is active, who has paid, who needs to renew, which events members attend, and how members engage over time.

Can I migrate from Memberful to Join It?

Yes. Organizations can move from Memberful to Join It by exporting member or subscriber data and importing it into Join It’s member database, with bulk import included for free on every Join It plan.

Expand Answer

A Memberful migration starts by identifying which records represent organization members rather than only content subscribers. Bring over names, emails, membership plans, statuses, renewal dates, and payment-related history where available. Join It can then structure those records into membership types, custom fields, renewal workflows, and member portal access. This gives your team a membership operations system while any content platform can remain focused on publishing or audience engagement.

Purple dot background gradient

Top-rated customer support

4.7 Stars on Capterra

Purple dot background gradient
ZFIT found Join It to be very simple to understand due to its clean layout and stellar customer support. Would highly recommend to anyone looking for membership software!
ZFIT
Bernd Z.
The Modern Whig Institute appreciated how easy it was to set up their membership program and then make adjustments as needed. Would highly recommend Join It to others.
Modern Whig Institute
Kevin J Rogers
Easily handles our membership management needs with a minimum of fuss. Excellent value for the money. Tremendous customer support (can't say this enough!)
The Orient Association
Tony A.

Try Join It and see the difference

No pressure. No credit card. Just modern membership software that works the way you do.

30 day free trial
Transparent pricing
Quick setup and live support
Sofware advice star badge
GetApp user reviews star badge
Capterra star badge